“You should try It’s Just Lunch,” suggested my friend Kristen. “It’s a professional matchmaker that fixes you up on actual dates.”
My fellow single mother was dropping me off after a black-tie school event that we had both attended solo.
“No swiping?” I asked, referring to Bumble, The League, Tinder and the other free apps where one sorts others’ profile pictures by swiping right (for yay) and left (for nay). It’s Just Lunch charges a fee, as do other professional services like Master Matchmakers and Love and Matchmaking.
“It’s more like a headhunting service,” Kristen explained. “But for a guy instead of a job.”
Since my divorce a decade earlier, I had experimented with Match and Bumble, but the selection of men was limited. I decided to investigate.
At my in-person interview, I filled out a questionnaire that grilled me on my preferences of a prospective mate’s income level, body type, religion and many other criteria. The process reminded me of setting the search filters on Wayfair.
This was no online bargain, however. The fee to join ranges, depending on the city you live in. For this amount of money, I could practically buy a time-share. The truth was my single status had become as comfortable as yoga pants. My two teenagers, new job and cadre of smart, funny girlfriends kept my life busy, happy and meaningful.
Still, every once in a while, I pined for male companionship. Someone to Netflix with and who would appreciate my new lingerie or latest Epicurious experiment — regular life stuff. Romance was like a black box that disappeared in the wreckage of my divorce.
“Think of it as making an investment in yourself,” encouraged Kristen.
I decided to go for it.
The next day I got a call from Brandi at It’s Just Lunch.
“We’ve got a match for you!” she chirped merrily, her voice sounding like a game show host.
“David is a doctor! He is 6 foot 2 with blue eyes and has two sons, one in college and a senior in high school. He’s available this Friday!”
Beyond that, the date is blind, at least google-free. No photos or identifying details like last names, employment or home addresses are divulged.
Two days later I headed to the It’s Just Lunch-designated restaurant and slid into the booth across from David. Stiffly, we both said hello. It felt awkward, like a job interview. We ordered wine and fell into conversation. David was Ivy-league educated, and had monogrammed cuffs and an intense stare.